FA Cup
- Winners: 1894
- Finalists: 1891
Second Division (1892–1992), First Division (1992–2004), The Championship (2004–present)
- Champions: 1896–97, 1913–14, 1922–23
- Runners-Up: 1894–95, 1980–81
- Play-off Champions: 1990–91
Third Division (1958–92), Second Division (1992–2004), League One (2004–present)
- Runners-Up: 1972–73
- Play-off Champions 1989–90
Third Division South (1921–58)
- Champions: 1930–31, 1949–50
Fourth Division (1958–92), Third Division (1992–2004), League Two (2004–present)
- Champions: 1970–71, 1997–98, 2009–10
- Runners-Up: 1959–60
Anglo-Scottish Cup
- Runners-up: 1980–81
Anglo-Italian Cup
- Winners: 1994–95
- Runners-Up: 1993–94